Fly fishing, the other side of this sport that spinning anglers look at with great appreciation.
Everything’s just more delicate and take skill to do. And at the same time, it looks simpler than it is.
You got your rod, line, and then reel. This is the order that I, and probably many other anglers, have been choosing their fly tackle in.
But lately, all three have become equal for me. You can’t just carefully choose a rod, line, and then slap a random reel on there.
For little trout on streams, you can probably get away with that. But big fish require strong and durable reels.
Enough bragging for now, what are the actual best reels on the market, and how do you choose one?
Well, keep reading to discover the best fly reels on the market.
A Brief Look into Fly Fishing Reels
If you’re new to fly fishing, then you must understand these key concepts before talking about options. I’ll keep as simple and fast as possible.
Components and Functionality
A fly fishing reel consists of several components that work together to provide a smooth and efficient fishing experience. The most critical component is the arbor, which is the center spindle around which the line is wound. The arbor size determines the amount of backing and line that the reel can hold. It is essential to choose a reel with an arbor size that is appropriate for the type of fishing you will be doing.
Another crucial component of a fly fishing reel is the drag system. The drag system controls the amount of resistance that the fish feels when it pulls on the line. A good drag system will allow you to tire the fish out without breaking the line or losing your catch. The drag system can be either a disc drag or a click and pawl drag, with the disc drag being the most common and effective.
The backing is a thin, strong line that is attached to the arbor and provides extra line for fighting larger fish. The leader is a tapered line that is attached to the end of the fly line and is used to present the fly to the fish. It is essential to choose a reel that can hold an appropriate amount of backing and that is compatible with the type of line you will be using.
Types of Fly Reels
There are several types of fly fishing reels available, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. The most common types are single-action, multiplier, and automatic reels.
Single-action reels are the most traditional and simple type of fly fishing reel. They are easy to use and maintain, and they provide a smooth and consistent drag system. Multiplier reels are more complex and provide a higher line retrieval rate. Automatic reels are the easiest to use, as they automatically retrieve the line when the handle is turned.
Size and Weight Considerations
The size and weight of the fly reel are important considerations when selecting a reel. The size of the reel should match the weight of the rod you are using. For example, if you are using a 5-weight rod, you should choose a 5-weight reel. If you use a reel that is too heavy or too light for your rod, it can affect the balance of your setup and make casting more difficult.
The weight of the reel is also important. Heavier reels are generally sturdier and can handle bigger fish, while lighter reels are less bulky and easier to cast for extended periods. When selecting a reel, consider the type of fish you will be targeting and choose a reel that is appropriate for the size of the fish.
Material and Construction
The quality of the construction and materials used in the fly reel is also an important consideration. High-quality reels are made from materials such as aluminum, titanium, or carbon fiber, which are lightweight and durable. Cheaper reels may be made from plastic or inferior metals, which can be prone to corrosion and damage.
The construction of the reel is also important. Look for reels that have a solid, one-piece frame, as this will provide greater strength and durability. Reels with sealed drag systems are also a good choice, as they are less likely to become damaged by water, dirt, or debris.
In conclusion, a quality fly fishing reel is an essential component of any fly fishing setup. Understanding the components and functionality of a fly fishing reel, as well as the different types available, will help you choose the right reel for your needs.
Top Picks for Freshwater Fly Fishing
Now that you have the base knowledge of fly reels, let’s see the best options on the market. We’ll start with freshwater.
Best All-Around Freshwater Reel
If you want a reel that will perform well in most scenarios, you should get something like the Orvis Hydros.
The Orvis Hydros fly reel is a solid all-around performer that offers a great balance between quality and affordability. Renowned for its versatility, the Hydros can seamlessly transition between targeting small trout in mountain streams to chasing larger species like bass in lakes and rivers. The reel’s design features a large arbor for quick line retrieval, reducing the time it takes to bring in a fish or recast after a missed strike.
Crafted from a strong, yet lightweight aluminum, the Hydros provides durability without weighing down the rod. Its sealed drag system is a standout feature, ensuring protection from the elements while delivering smooth and consistent drag pressure. This system is also easily adjustable, which is critical when fighting fish that have a wide range of power and speed.
Orvis has a reputation for creating gear that lasts, and the Hydros is no exception. It’s a reel that can be counted on for performance and endurance. Whether you’re a beginner or an experienced angler, the Hydros is a reliable choice that won’t disappoint.
See the Orvis Hydros on BassPro.
Best Fly Reels for Trout
Trout fishing requires a reel with a smooth drag system that can handle the fight of these feisty fish.
I highly recommend the Hatch Iconic 4+. This reel has a sealed drag system that provides consistent, reliable performance, and it is lightweight and easy to handle.
The Hatch Iconic 4+ fly reel is a remarkable piece of gear for the picky angler targeting trout. Its robust construction is immediately noticed, with a design that promises to handle the most challenging game fish, yet it maintains a level of delicacy suitable for trout fishing. The reel, proudly made in Southern California, is not only a testament to quality craftsmanship but also to functional design, striking a balance between size and weight that makes it ideal for a 9-foot 5-weight rod.
Weighing in at 5.25 ounces, the Iconic 4+ provides a perfect balance for 4 to 6-weight rods. This reel is more than just a trout reel; it’s a versatile tool that can transition from small streams to larger rivers. The anodized finish and the attention to detail in the machining are marks of a reel built to last and to perform. The Iconic 4+ is a premium reel that reflects Hatch Outdoors’ commitment to excellence and is a worthy investment for anglers seeking reliability and performance in their trout fishing expeditions.
See it on the official website.
Another great option for trout fishing is the Galvan Torque fly reel, which has a best-in-class drag system and is made in the USA.
The Galvan Torque fly reel is an exceptional piece of equipment for the trout angler seeking a blend of reliability and aesthetic appeal. This reel stands out with its aggressive CNC machining, which not only gives it a distinctive look but also reduces weight, making it a comfortable companion for long days on the water. The Torque is recognized as Galvan’s flagship model, and it’s clear why: it offers a smooth drag system that can be finely tuned to protect light tippets, yet is robust enough to handle the unexpected runs of larger trout.
Though it may have a slightly slower retrieve compared to some competitors, this does not significantly detract from its performance. The Torque’s quality is further evidenced by its durability and the high standards to which it is lauded. Overall, the Galvan Torque is a top-tier reel that promises to enhance the trout fishing experience with its fine craftsmanship and dependable operation.
See it on Amazon.
Options for Bass and Other Freshwater Fish
For bass and other larger freshwater fish, regardless of budget, a specific high-quality option is the Hatch Finatic Gen 2 fly reel. This reel is known for its durability, strong drag system, and versatility across different fishing conditions. The Hatch Finatic Gen 2 offers a sealed drag system that is both smooth and powerful, making it ideal for handling the aggressive runs of bass and other large fish.
The reel’s construction is top-notch, with a type 2 anodized finish that can withstand the rigors of freshwater and saltwater environments. It comes in various sizes, but for bass fishing, the 7 Plus or 9 Plus models would provide the necessary backing capacity and drag strength for larger fish.
For those on a budget, the Lamson Liquid -9+ is a great option that provides good performance at a lower price point.
Despite its entry-level price point, the Liquid doesn’t skimp on the features that matter most. It boasts Lamson’s signature conical drag system, which is typically reserved for higher-end models, providing a surprising level of stopping power and smoothness necessary for controlling spirited bass. This drag system is sealed and maintenance-free, offering durability and reliability when it’s needed the most.
The construction of the reel is thoughtful, with a pressure-cast aluminum frame and spool that strike a balance between strength and weight. This makes it suitable for long days on the water without causing arm fatigue. The Liquid’s design is simple yet functional, with an emphasis on practical performance over flashy aesthetics. The reel delivers around 5-7 pounds of drag force, which is more than adequate for bass fishing scenarios. Overall, the Lamson Liquid is a standout reel in the budget category, offering features that are competitive with much pricier options on the market.
Best Click-and-Pawl
For the OG’s wanting a classic fly fishing experience, the Hardy Marquis LWT might be just what you need.
The Hardy Marquis LWT harkens back to the golden age of fly fishing, offering a classic aesthetic with modern functionality. This reel is a re-engineered version of the beloved original Marquis, maintaining the timeless look and feel while incorporating contemporary materials and machining techniques for improved performance. The reel’s body is crafted from high-grade aluminum, ensuring strength and durability while keeping weight to a minimum.
The Marquis LWT features a click-check drag system that provides the essential sound and simplicity favored by traditionalists, yet offers enough resistance to fight spirited fish effectively. Its classic design is not just for show; it has a practical purpose, with a large arbor that increases line retrieval rates and helps reduce line memory.
Anglers who appreciate the history and tradition of the sport will find the Hardy Marquis LWT to be more than just a reel; it’s a piece of fly fishing heritage. It offers the tactile connection to the past that many modern reels lack, without compromising on the quality and reliability required by today’s anglers.
Check the Marquis out on Amazon.
Best Fly Reel Under $100
If you’re looking for a quality fly reel that won’t break the bank, the Piscifun Sword Fly Fishing Reel is an excellent choice. This reel has a solid construction and a smooth drag system that can handle a variety of fish species. It also has a large arbor design that allows for quick line retrieval and reduces line memory.
See the Piscifun Sword on Amazon.
Another great option is the Redington Crosswater Fly Reel. This reel is lightweight and durable, with a strong drag system that can handle big fish. It also has a large arbor design that helps to reduce line memory and increase line retrieval speed.
See the Redington Crosswater on Amazon.
Best Saltwater Fly Reels
The saltwater environment can be harsh on equipment, so you need a fly reel that is durable and can withstand the elements. In this section, I will share my top picks for the best saltwater fly reels.
Best Inshore Fly Reel
One of the best inshore fly fishing reels that consistently receives high praise for its performance, durability, and versatility is the Nautilus CCF-X2. This reel is designed to handle the challenges of inshore fishing, where species like redfish, snook, and seatrout demand a reel with a strong, smooth drag system and resistance to the corrosive saltwater environment.
The Nautilus CCF-X2 features a dual drag system that provides substantial stopping power with minimal start-up inertia, which is critical for protecting light tippets and managing fast-running fish. The reel’s construction includes a lightweight aluminum frame and spool, with a hard anodizing treatment to resist corrosion. The large arbor design ensures quick line pickup and helps to keep the line memory-free.
You’ll appreciate the CCF-X2 for its ease of maintenance and the ability to switch spools quickly. Its reputation for toughness and reliability, combined with a sleek design, makes it a top choice for inshore fly fishing aficionados.
But, if this reel doesn’t fit your budget, something like the Redington Behemot.
This reel offers a fantastic value with features that are typically found in more expensive models. The Behemoth boasts an impressive drag system that utilizes a carbon fiber disc to provide powerful, smooth, and reliable drag performance, which is essential for handling the quick runs of inshore species.
The die-cast construction of the Behemoth reel provides durability while still keeping the weight manageable, and its large arbor design facilitates rapid line retrieval—a crucial feature when fishing in saltwater environments where fish can cover a lot of ground quickly. Additionally, the oversized drag knob allows for easy adjustments, even with wet hands or when wearing gloves.
While the Behemoth may not have the same cachet or refinement as some higher-end reels, its performance-to-price ratio is hard to beat. It’s a solid choice if you want a reliable functionality for inshore fly fishing without breaking the bank.
See the Behemoth on Amazon.
Best Offshore Fly Reel
For offshore fly fishing, where the equipment must withstand the toughest saltwater conditions and the most powerful fish species, one of the best reels on the market is the Tibor Gulfstream. Designed by master reel designer Ted Juracsik, the Gulfstream is built to handle large saltwater game such as tuna, sailfish, and even smaller marlin.
The Tibor Gulfstream features a robust, maintenance-free drag system that can be finely tuned to the your preference and provides the stopping power needed for big fish. Its large arbor design ensures quick line pickup, which is essential when fish make long, fast runs. The reel is constructed from solid aluminum, which is anodized for superior corrosion resistance—a must-have for the harsh saltwater environment.
Renowned for its durability and reliability, the Tibor Gulfstream is a favorite among seasoned offshore fly anglers. Its reputation for quality is backed by a lifetime warranty, making it not just a purchase but an investment in your fly fishing adventures.
See the Tibor Gulfstream on Amazon.
A more affordable option for saltwater fly fishing would be the Redington Grande.
This reel is designed to offer the strength and performance needed for the demanding conditions of offshore angling at a more accessible price point. The Grande features a fully anodized, machined aluminum construction that provides excellent corrosion resistance against saltwater.
The reel’s robust sealed Super-Torque drag system can handle the hard-fighting species you’re likely to encounter in offshore waters, offering smooth and consistent drag pressure. The V-spool design not only increases backing capacity but also aids in faster line retrieval, a critical aspect when battling fast-moving fish.
Despite being a budget-conscious option, the Redington Grande doesn’t skimp on quality. It’s a durable and well-built reel that provides the necessary features for a successful offshore fly fishing experience. This reel is a smart choice if you want dependable performance without the high-end price tag.
Now, I know what you’re thinking. This reel costs $300, and I’m considering it a budget option? Well, it’s more of an investment than just another expensive item. You spend a few hundred now, but you use the reel for many years to come. And also, offshore saltwater fishing requires good materials and strong components, so going cheap isn’t a good option at all.
See the Redington Grande on Amazon.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-rated fly reels for trout fishing?
As a fly fishing enthusiast, I can say that the Galvan Torque is an excellent choice for the serious fly angler who spends a considerable amount of time on the water. The Echo Ion fly reel is also a terrific choice for anyone who doesn’t want to spend a lot of fortune on their fishing gear.
Which fly reels have stood the test of time as the best?
The Hardy Duchess is a classic reel that has stood the test of time and is still a favorite among many fly fishermen. The Abel SDS 9/10 is also a great option for those looking for a high-quality and durable fly reel.
How do you determine the appropriate budget for a quality fly reel?
When it comes to determining the appropriate budget for a quality fly reel, it’s important to consider the features you need and the type of fishing you will be doing. Quality fly reels can range from $100 to over $1000, so it’s important to find a balance between your budget and the features you need.
What features should I look for in a fly reel for salmon fishing?
When looking for a fly reel for salmon fishing, it’s important to consider the drag system, line capacity, and overall durability of the reel. Some great options for salmon fishing include the Cheeky Limitless 425 and the Galvan Torque.
What are the benefits of investing in a high-end fly reel?
Investing in a high-end fly reel can provide many benefits, including increased durability, smoother drag, and better overall performance. High-end reels also often come with better warranties and customer support.
Can you recommend a fly reel that pairs well with a 5-weight fly rod?
If you’re looking for a fly reel that pairs well with a 5-weight fly rod, the Maxcatch AVID PRO Fly Fishing Reel is a great option. It’s affordable, durable, and provides a smooth drag system that will help you land more fish.
